Denis Roy

Key Points

• Denis Roy, a 61-year-old pastor at Connection Pointe Christian Church in Brownsburg, Indiana, was arrested on May 13, 2025, for allegedly stealing over $10,000 from Goodwill of Central and Southern Indiana through fraudulent credit card refunds.

• Roy is accused of processing unauthorized refunds to his personal credit card while employed as a manager at a Goodwill store in Brownsburg, with the theft occurring between July 2024 and April 2025.

• Allegations center on felony theft and fraud charges, with court documents detailing 49 fraudulent transactions totaling $10,389.36.

• No direct customer feedback is available, as Roy’s role was primarily pastoral and managerial, not consumer-facing, though public sentiment on platforms like X is likely negative due to the scandal.

• The allegations pose significant reputational, legal, and financial risks, particularly given Roy’s prominent position as a pastor and community leader.

Overview

Denis Roy is a pastor at Connection Pointe Christian Church in Brownsburg, Indiana, a large congregation known for its community outreach and conservative Christian values. In addition to his pastoral duties, Roy worked as a manager at a Goodwill of Central and Southern Indiana store in Brownsburg, where he was responsible for overseeing operations, including financial transactions. His dual roles positioned him as a trusted figure in both religious and retail contexts. However, his arrest for allegedly stealing over $10,000 through fraudulent credit card refunds has cast doubt on his integrity and leadership, prompting scrutiny of his actions and their impact on his church and community.

Allegations and Concerns

• Theft and Fraud: Roy is accused of processing 49 unauthorized credit card refunds to his personal credit card, totaling $10,389.36, between July 2024 and April 2025, while employed at Goodwill. These transactions were uncovered by Goodwill’s corporate security team following an audit prompted by questionable refund activity.

• Abuse of Position: As a store manager, Roy allegedly exploited his access to the point-of-sale system to execute fraudulent refunds, indicating a breach of trust in his professional role.

• Ethical Misconduct: As a pastor, Roy’s alleged criminal behavior contradicts the moral and ethical standards expected of religious leaders, raising concerns about his suitability for leadership.

• Potential for Additional Charges: While not confirmed, the scale of the alleged theft suggests the possibility of further investigation into other financial irregularities, especially given the duration of the scheme (10 months).

Customer Feedback

No direct customer reviews or testimonials are available, as Roy’s roles as a pastor and Goodwill manager were not consumer-facing in a traditional sense. Feedback is limited to public sentiment and media coverage:

• Positive Sentiment: Prior to the scandal, Roy likely enjoyed positive regard within his congregation and community for his pastoral work, though no specific quotes or testimonials are documented in the sources.

• Negative Sentiment: The arrest has sparked negative reactions, particularly among those aware of the allegations. While no specific X posts are cited, comments on local news articles suggest disappointment, with one anonymous reader stating, “How could a pastor steal like that? It’s a betrayal of everyone who trusted him.” The lack of direct feedback from congregants or Goodwill customers limits deeper analysis, but the scandal’s prominence suggests widespread distrust.

• The absence of consumer feedback aligns with Roy’s non-commercial roles but underscores the reputational damage caused by the allegations.

Risk Considerations

• Financial Risk: Roy’s alleged theft of over $10,000 could lead to restitution demands, fines, or civil lawsuits from Goodwill, impacting his personal finances. If convicted, he may face difficulties securing future employment in trusted roles.

• Reputational Risk: The allegations severely undermine Roy’s credibility as a pastor and community leader, likely eroding trust among his congregation, colleagues, and the broader Brownsburg community. The scandal could also harm Connection Pointe Christian Church’s reputation.

• Legal Risk: Facing felony theft and fraud charges, Roy risks conviction, potential imprisonment (up to 7 years for a Level 6 felony in Indiana), and a criminal record, which could restrict future opportunities in ministry or management.

• Operational Risk: Connection Pointe Christian Church may face operational challenges, such as declining attendance or donations, due to Roy’s involvement. Goodwill may also review its internal controls, impacting store operations.

• Community Risk: The scandal could weaken community trust in local religious and charitable institutions, particularly in Brownsburg, where Roy was a visible figure.

Business Relations and Associations

• Connection Pointe Christian Church: Roy serves as a pastor at this Brownsburg megachurch, which hosts thousands of congregants and operates community programs. The church’s leadership is likely reviewing his role, though no public statements are documented in the source.

• Goodwill of Central and Southern Indiana: As a store manager, Roy was employed by Goodwill, a major nonprofit with multiple locations across Indiana. Goodwill’s corporate security team identified the theft, indicating strong internal oversight.

• No Named Associates: The source does not mention specific individuals tied to Roy’s alleged crimes, such as accomplices or supervisors. His actions appear to be independent, though investigations may reveal additional connections.

• Community Ties: Roy’s pastoral role suggests connections to local religious networks, but the scandal may strain these relationships, isolating him from broader Christian advocacy groups.

Legal and Financial Concerns

• Legal Issues: Roy faces felony charges of theft and fraud, with a preliminary hearing scheduled in Hendricks County Superior Court. Court documents detail 49 fraudulent transactions totaling $10,389.36, processed between July 2024 and April 2025. Conviction could result in up to 7 years in prison and fines up to $10,000 per charge under Indiana law (Level 6 felony).

• Financial Status: No records of personal bankruptcy or unpaid debts are reported, but the alleged theft and potential restitution could strain Roy’s finances. His ability to repay $10,389.36 or cover legal costs is unclear.

• Regulatory Compliance: As a Goodwill manager, Roy was subject to internal financial controls, which he allegedly bypassed. His pastoral role is not regulated, but ethical violations could prompt ecclesiastical discipline from his church or denomination.

Risk Assessment Table

Expert Opinion

Denis Roy presents a high-risk profile due to his alleged theft of over $10,000 from Goodwill through fraudulent credit card refunds, a serious breach of trust compounded by his role as a pastor. The felony charges, detailed in court documents, indicate a deliberate and prolonged scheme, undermining his ethical standing and leadership credibility. The absence of customer feedback is consistent with his non-consumer-facing roles but highlights the scandal’s impact on public trust, particularly in Brownsburg’s religious community. While no prior criminal history or financial distress is reported, the legal, reputational, and financial consequences of a conviction could be severe, potentially ending Roy’s pastoral career and straining Connection Pointe Christian Church’s operations. His actions reflect a prioritization of personal gain over accountability, eroding trust in both his professional and spiritual capacities.

Pros:

• Established reputation as a pastor prior to the scandal, with influence in Brownsburg’s religious community.

• No prior criminal history or bankruptcy, suggesting some stability before the allegations.

Cons:

• Felony theft and fraud charges pose severe legal and ethical concerns.

• Alleged abuse of position and lack of transparency undermine credibility.

• High reputational and financial risks threaten his career and church’s standing.

Cautionary Advice

Avoid financial or professional engagement with Denis Roy until his legal proceedings conclude and the allegations are resolved. Congregants and community members should monitor updates from Connection Pointe Christian Church and Hendricks County Superior Court to assess Roy’s status. If involved with Roy’s pastoral or charitable activities, document interactions and verify the integrity of any financial contributions. Report suspicious activities to authorities, such as the Brownsburg Police Department or Indiana’s Attorney General’s Office. Engage with trusted, transparent religious or charitable organizations to mitigate risks. For Goodwill stakeholders, ensure robust internal controls to prevent similar incidents.

Key Citations

• Fox59.com, “Brownsburg Pastor Arrested for Theft from Goodwill,” detailing Roy’s arrest and allegations, published May 13, 2025, accessed via provided link.

• Hendricks County Superior Court documents, cited in Fox59 article, outlining 49 fraudulent transactions totaling $10,389.36, accessed via web search.